Bermudian recipe

Bermuda Fish Sandwich

Bermuda's favourite lunch: crisp fried fish piled on toasted raisin bread or white bread with tartar sauce, coleslaw, cheese, lettuce and tomato.

Prep
25 min
Cook
15 min
Total
40 min
Servings
4
Difficulty
Beginner
Course
Lunch
Jump to recipe

Served with Tartar sauce. Mayonnaise with chopped pickles or capers, shallot or chives, parsley and lemon. More about Tartar sauce

Served with Relish. Chopped pickled vegetables, often cucumber, peppers and onion, sweetened and spiced. More about Relish

About this dish

The fish sandwich is Bermuda's best-known lunch, sold from takeaway counters and beach shacks all over the island. Thick fillets of local fish, usually wahoo, rockfish or snapper, are dipped in seasoned flour and fried until crisp, then stacked on toasted bread with tartar sauce and coleslaw. The Bermudian twist is the bread: many people order it on raisin bread, whose sweetness plays against the hot, salty fish, while others stick with plain white bread. Toppings are up to you, and a 'full' sandwich often has cheese, tomato, lettuce and onion as well, finished with a few drops of hot sauce or sherry peppers sauce.

Instructions

  1. Make the tartar sauce: stir the mayonnaise, relish, onion, lemon juice and parsley together and chill until needed.

  2. Make the coleslaw: mix the cabbage and carrot with the mayonnaise, vinegar, sugar and salt. Set aside so the cabbage softens a little.

  3. Pat the fish dry and cut it into 4 pieces about the size of your bread slices. In a shallow dish, mix the flour, Lawry's Seasoned Salt, pepper, paprika, garlic powder and thyme. Put the beaten egg and milk in a second dish.

  4. Heat the oil in a large heavy frying pan over medium-high heat to about 350°F (175°C), or until a pinch of flour sizzles at once.

  5. Dip each piece of fish in the seasoned flour, then the egg, then the flour again, pressing so it sticks. Fry 3 to 4 minutes per side, until deep golden and the fish flakes easily in the middle. Drain on a rack or paper towels and sprinkle with a little more seasoned salt.

  6. If using cheese, lay a slice on each hot fillet straight out of the pan so it melts.

  7. Butter the bread lightly and toast it in a dry pan or under the grill until golden. Raisin bread browns quickly, so watch it.

  8. Spread tartar sauce on 4 slices of toast. Add the fish, then coleslaw, tomato, lettuce and onion as you like, and a few drops of hot sauce. Top with the remaining toast and eat while the fish is hot.

Cooking tips

Raisin bread is the classic Bermudian choice: its sweetness against the salty fish and sharp tartar sauce is what makes the sandwich. White bread works for anyone who prefers it plain. Lawry's Seasoned Salt is already salty, so taste before adding any plain salt. Fry the fish in two batches so the oil stays hot and the coating stays crisp. Sherry peppers sauce is a Bermudian table sauce of hot peppers steeped in sherry and spices; any vinegar-based hot sauce will do instead.

Storage

Best eaten straight away. Leftover fried fish keeps 2 days in the fridge; reheat in a hot oven for 10 minutes to crisp it before building the sandwich. Tartar sauce keeps 4 days and coleslaw 2 days, both chilled.

Find more recipes like this

Frequently asked questions

Where does Bermuda Fish Sandwich come from?

Bermuda Fish Sandwich is a dish from Bermuda. Bermuda's favourite lunch: crisp fried fish piled on toasted raisin bread or white bread with tartar sauce, coleslaw, cheese, lettuce and tomato.

How long does it take to make Bermuda Fish Sandwich?

About 40 min in total: 25 min of prep and 15 min of cooking. The recipe serves 4.

Is Bermuda Fish Sandwich pescatarian or nut free?

Yes. As written, this recipe is pescatarian and nut free. If you cook for allergies, check the labels on stocks, sauces and spice blends.

Can I make Bermuda Fish Sandwich ahead or store leftovers?

Best eaten straight away. Leftover fried fish keeps 2 days in the fridge; reheat in a hot oven for 10 minutes to crisp it before building the sandwich. Tartar sauce keeps 4 days and coleslaw 2 days, both chilled.

Be the first to share a photo

We don't have a photo of this dish yet. Make it, snap it, and yours could be the one everyone sees.

You might also like